Snubs & Surprises in the 2024 Oscar SongShortlists
Bruce Springsteen, Jack Black and Justin Timberlake: Variety no longer surely feel depraved. It occurs. Bruce Springsteen onstage at the DARLENE LOVE: Like for the Holidays match at The Town Corridor on November 30, 2023 in Modern York, Modern York. John Nacion for Billboard When Bruce Springsteen’s “Addicted to Romance” from She Came to Me
Bruce Springsteen, Jack Black and Justin Timberlake: Variety no longer surely feel depraved. It occurs.
Bruce Springsteen onstage at the DARLENE LOVE: Like for the Holidays match at The Town Corridor on November 30, 2023 in Modern York, Modern York.John Nacion for Billboard
When Bruce Springsteen’s “Addicted to Romance” from She Came to Me and Jack Black’s “Peaches” from The Intellectual Mario Bros. Movie were nominated for Golden Globe Awards for simplest fashioned song 10 days in the pastmany expected them to be nominated for Oscars in that class too – or no lower than hold the shortlist of 15 contenders from which the nominees are chosen. But when the shortlist used to be announced on Thursday (Dec. 21), each songs were nowhere to be discovered.
For potentially the most part, despite the incontrovertible reality that, the pundits got it factual. More than a few this year’s highly touted songs and rankings were shortlisted for Oscars, as predicted.
Three songs from Barbie are shortlisted for simplest fashioned song. No shock there. The movie has been a excellent-searching hit.
The shortlisting of Lenny Kravitz’s “Street to Freedom” from Rustin and Olivia Rodrigo’s “Can’t Procure Me Now” from The Hunger Video games: The Ballad of Songbirds & Snakes were moreover expected.
Via simplest fashioned rankings, the behind Robbie Robertson used to be shortlisted, as expected, for Killers of the Flower Moon, the 12th and final Martin Scorsese movie that Robertson worked on. Robertson, who died in June at age 80, is vying to change into the first composer to be nominated in this class posthumously since Bernard Herrmann used to be cited in 1976 for everyObsessionandTaxi Driver.
Also expected were the shortlisting of John Williams’ rating for Indiana Jones and the Dial of DestinyLudwig Göransson’s rating for OppenheimerMica Levi’s rating for The Zone of Pastime and Daniel Pemberton’s rating for Spider-Man: Across the Spider-Verse.
But there were hundreds of snubs and surprises, too. Rob a explore.
-
Snub: Bruce Springsteen
The failure of “Addicted to Romance” from She Came to Me to hold the shortlist is terribly stunning given Springsteen’s Oscar historic past. He obtained simplest fashioned song in 1994 for “Streets of Philadelphia” and used to be nominated all all over again two years later for “Unnecessary Man Walkin’.” This is able to were his first nomination with a collaborator — his wife, Patti Scialfa.
-
Shock: Jon Batiste
Batiste has obtained an Oscar (for Soul) and five Grammys in the past three years, and he’s nominated for six more Grammys at the Feb. 4 ceremony, so we know he is extremely regarded. But American Symphonya Netflix documentary a few year in his lifestyles, did suddenly properly. It used to be shortlisted for simplest documentary feature, while Batiste used to be shortlisted for every simplest fashioned rating and simplest fashioned song (for co-writing “It Never Went Away” with Dan Wilson).
-
Snub: Alan Menken, Lin-Manuel Miranda
Menken and Miranda are each awards demonstrate royalty. Menken is an EGOT. Miranda will change into one as soon as he wins an Oscar (which is proving to be surprisingly refined). “For the First Time” from The Puny Mermaidwhich they co-wrote, used to be omitted for the shortlist for simplest fashioned song. Halle Bailey sings “For the First Time” onscreen in the movie. Menken obtained his first of 4Oscarsin this class for “Below the Sea” from the fashioned 1989 iteration ofThe Puny Mermaid.
-
Snub: Jack Black
Black co-wrote “Peaches” for The Intellectual Mario Bros. Moviewhich used to be the year’s 2nd-biggest hit at the sphere living of job, at the abet of simplest the sector-dominating Barbie. Besides co-writing and performing the song, Black used to be in the tantalizing movie’s disclose solid as Bowser. This is able to were the first Oscar nomination for Black, who obtained a Grammy for simplest steel performance 9 years in the past for a note he recorded with Tenacious D for a Ronnie James Dio tribute album. Black co-wrote “Peaches” with Aaron Horvath, Michael Jelenic, Eric Osmond and John Spiker.
-
Surprises: The Coloration Red, Flora and Son
Each person expected these motion photos to generate a simplest fashioned song contender. But few expected them each to generate two simplest fashioned song contenders, factual one skittish of Barbie. The 2 songs from The Coloration Red that are shortlisted are widely expected “Withhold It Movin’” and the more stunning “Superpower (I).” The 2 songs from Flora and Son that made the checklist are the widely expected “Excessive Lifestyles” and the more stunning “Meet in the Heart.”
-
Snub: Justin Timberlake
Timberlake used to be nominated for simplest fashioned song seven years in the past for co-writing “Can’t Fight the Feeling!” from the first Trollsnonetheless he wasn’t as lucky with “Better Attach” from Trolls Band Togetherwhich he co-wrote with Karl Schuster (Shellback) and Amy Allen. The *NSYNC single reached No. 25 on the Billboard Hot 100, whereas Timberlake’s earlier hit debuted at No. 1. Challenging characters compose “Better Attach” onscreen in the movie. Timberlake and the diversified members of *NSYNC are in the disclose solid, alongside with Anna Kendrick, Puny one Cudi, Troye Sivan, Camila Cabello and Anderson .Paak, among others.
-
Snub: Puny Richard
Puny Richard: I Am The entirety used to be omitted for a nod for simplest documentary feature. Paul McCartney, Billy Porter and John Waters seem in this doc relating to the rock ‘n’ roll icon who had a profound affect on tune and culture. He used to be a flamboyant gender-bender in the 1950s, when “Don’t Command Ecstatic” wasn’t factual a political slogan, it used to be an unwritten rule. Puny Richard used to be considered one of the inaugural inductees in the Rock and Roll Corridor of Standing in 1986. He obtained a lifetime success award from the Recording Academy in 1993. He died in 2020 at age 87.
-
Shock: John & Yoko
War Is Over! Inspired by the Song of John & Yoko is among 15 motion photos shortlisted for simplest tantalizing short movie. John Lennon obtained an Oscar in 1971 as a member of The Beatles, who obtained simplest fashioned song rating for Let It Be. The neighborhood had broken up by that time; none of them were on hand to accept, so Quincy Jones, who used to be that year’s tune director, accredited on their behalf.
-
Snub: Trent Reznor & Atticus Ross
The 2-time Oscar winners were omitted for his or her rating for The Killer. This is able to were the fourth nod in this class for Reznor and Ross followingThe Social Community,LackandSoul(a collaboration with Jon Batiste). David Fincher, who directedThe Social CommunityandLackmoreover directedThe Killer.
-
Shock: Wes Anderson
Nobody must be deal surprised when Wes Anderson does properly at the Oscars. He has obtained seven nominations in four categories – simplest portray, simplest directing, simplest tantalizing feature movie (twice) and simplest fashioned screenplay (three events). Now, he has an opportunity to land a nomination in a fifth class as “Dear Alien (Who Art work in Heaven)” from Asteroid Metropolis made potentially the most curious fashioned song shortlist. Anderson co-wrote the song with Richard Hawley and Pulp frontman Jarvis Cocker.
-
Snub: Alexandre Desplat
The French composer, an Oscar perennial, used to be omitted for his rating for Nyad. This is able to were his 12th nomination in this class, all since 2006. That’s more than anyone else has accrued in that length. Desplat has obtained twice, forThe Huge Budapest HotelandThe Shape of Water. This is able to were Desplat’s first nod in the 2020s, following three in the 2000s and eight in the 2010s.
-
Snub: Branford Marsalis
This is able to be the first Oscar nomination for the jazz saxophonist. That movie has a shortlisted song (Lenny Kravitz’s “Street to Freedom”), nonetheless Marsalis’ rating used to be no longer acknowledged. Marsalis is a 3-time Grammy winner. He obtained a Primetime Emmy nod two years in the past for critical tune composition for a documentary sequence or particular forTulsa Burning: The 1921 Bustle Massacre.
-
Shock: Brand Orton
The composer used to be shortlisted for his rating for the most up-to-date Alexander Payne movie, The Holdovers. Which implies Orton got more votes this traipse-spherical than such past Oscar winners in this class as Alexandre Desplat (Nyad), Hanz Zimmer (The Creator) and Hildur Guðnadóttir (A Haunting in Venice).
-
Snubs: Julia Michaels and Linda Perry
Each and each of these songwriters own obtained two Grammy nods for song of the year, nonetheless they missed the shortlist with songs they wrote one after the other for motion photos this year. Michaels missed out with “This Need,” which she co-wrote with Benjamin Rice and JP Saxe for the Disney movie, Need. Perry used to be omitted for “Rep a Arrangement” from Nyad.
Michaels and Saxe obtained a Grammy nod for song of the year three years in the past for his or her collaboration “If the World Used to be Ending.” Michaels’ first nod in that class used to be for co-writing her breakthrough hit, “Points.” Ariana DeBose, an Oscar winner for theWest Aspect Epicremake, sings “This Need.” She’s moreover in the disclose solid, alongside with Chris Pine and Victor Garber.
-
Snub: Christopher Contain & Daniel Rossen
The musicians were expected to hold the shortlist with their rating for Celine Song’s feature directorial debut Past Lives. Contain and Rossen are members of frail indie rock band Grizzly Contain, which has landed two high 10 albums on the Billboard 200.